AFPUB-2012-GEN-001-DRAFT-02

AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · The 2012 agenda schedules an Anycast discussion without endorsing its outcome or substance.

条件: One agenda entry is available; a scheduled discussion does not establish consensus.

2012/05/05

1715 - 1800 Proposal: AfriNIC Region Anycast Assignments (McTim)

No Reverse Unless Assigned

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · The same tentative agenda schedules No rDNS Unless Assigned. It supplies no personal position to compare over time.

条件: The sender acts on behalf of the PDWG chairs.

2012/05/05

0900 - 0945 Proposal: No rDNS Unless Assigned (McTim)

2012/05/05

Ernest (on behalf of PDWG Chairs)

Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC region

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · The February 2015 notice reports Board ratification of draft-04 and staff preparations for implementation. Reporting those institutional actions does not establish the sender's own policy preference.

条件: The notice does not verify that implementation was completed.

2015/02/12

We are pleased to inform you that the AFRINIC Board has ratified the following policy proposal:

2015/02/12

AFRINIC staff is taking appropriate measures to effect it's immediate implementation.

Out-Of-Region Use of AFRINIC Internet Number Resources

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · The May 2015 notice points readers to an author-supplied update and requests a changelog; it expresses no personal support or opposition.

条件: An announcement that a proposal will be discussed is not a decision on that proposal.

2015/05/27

The author has provided an update to the proposal "Out-Of-Region Use of AFRINIC Internet Number Resources"

2015/05/27

Douglas, please feel free to summarize the updates & changelog to the list for the convenience of the readers.

AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01 · No Reverse Unless Assigned

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · Putting two proposals on one agenda is evidence of meeting coordination, not agreement with either proposal or a comparison of their merits.

条件: These two entries come from the same communication, not two independent statements of preference.

2012/05/05

1715 - 1800 Proposal: AfriNIC Region Anycast Assignments (McTim)

2012/05/05

0900 - 0945 Proposal: No rDNS Unless Assigned (McTim)

AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01 · Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC region

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · The earlier Anycast agenda entry and the later Anycast ratification notice concern different recorded proposals and procedural stages. They do not show that Ernest changed or maintained a personal policy position.

条件: Do not infer continuity of draft text or completed implementation from the shared Anycast subject.

2012/05/05

1715 - 1800 Proposal: AfriNIC Region Anycast Assignments (McTim)

2015/02/12

ID: AFPUB-2014-GEN-003-DRAFT-04 Name: Anycast Assignments in the AFRINIC region

Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC region · Out-Of-Region Use of AFRINIC Internet Number Resources

評価: 一貫性を評価するには証拠が不十分です · Reporting ratification of Anycast and forwarding an Out-of-Region update are compatible administrative acts, but neither supplies a personal substantive position for a cross-policy consistency judgment.

条件: Institutional decisions and an author's update must not be attributed to the messenger as personal votes.

2015/02/12

We are pleased to inform you that the AFRINIC Board has ratified the following policy proposal:

2015/05/27

The author has provided an update to the proposal