- Gov. Newsom’s veto of SB 1047 highlights the ongoing debate over AI regulation.
- The decision underscores the need for a balanced approach to AI safety, avoiding over-regulation.
OUR TAKE
The veto reflects the ongoing tension between the desire to regulate emerging technologies and the need to encourage innovation. While the bill’s failure to pass may slow the progression of AI safety regulations in California, the conversation around the need for responsible AI development is likely to continue. Both supporters and opponents of the bill agree on the importance of addressing AI risks, suggesting that the debate over the best approach to regulation is far from over.
–Rebecca Xu, BTW reporter
What happened
California Governor Gavin Newsom has vetoed SB 1047, a comprehensive artificial intelligence safety bill. He argued that the legislation, while well-intentioned, would primarily target large companies and overlook critical factors such as the deployment context of AI systems. Newsom highlighted that 32 of the top 50 AI firms are based in California, suggesting that the bill’s stringent standards could stifle innovation without adequately addressing safety concerns. He pointed out that the bill failed to differentiate between high-risk and low-risk AI applications, potentially undermining its intended safety benefits.
Newsom has previously signed other AI-related bills aimed at regulating performance replicas and addressing misinformation, indicating a commitment to responsible AI governance.
Also read: California passes new laws to protect performers from AI misuse
Also read: California approves legislation to tighten AI regulation
Why it’s important
The veto is a significant setback for those advocating for greater oversight and regulation of AI development. It means that, for now, there will be no stringent state-level regulation mandating safety testing and public disclosure of safety protocols for AI models in California. Critics of the bill, including Governor Newsom, argued that it did not differentiate between AI systems deployed in high-risk environments and those that were not, applying stringent standards even to basic functions if deployed by a large system.
The debate around SB 1047 has brought the issue of AI safety to the forefront, highlighting the need for a balanced approach that fosters innovation while addressing potential risks. Governor Newsom has announced plans to work with industry experts to develop more workable guardrails around AI models, focusing on analysing their capabilities and risks.
