RIPE NCC · RIR 워치독
Voluntary Transfer Lock
안건별 기록은 여기서 확인하세요. 무엇이 바뀌었고, 왜 중요했는지, 누가 무엇을 주장했는지, 입장이 어떻게 변했는지, 무엇이 결정되었으며, 근거가 아직 부족한 부분은 어디인지 담고 있습니다.
출처 정보
- Policy ID
- 2023-03
- RIR
- RIPE NCC
- 공식 지위
- Accepted
- 도입됨
- 2023. 3. 8.
- 마지막 소스 업데이트
- 2026. 11. 18.
실제로 이 논쟁을 이끈 이는 누구일까?
정책 변화 과정
Strength of constraints, recommendations and implementation choices · Version 2 explicitly distinguishes mandatory constraints, recommendations that need a strong reason for departure, and optional implementation choices that must be documented. This clarifies the force of the existing three sections. It does not change the resource types covered, the exclusion of legacy resources, or the irrevocability of an agreed lock.
출처 정보 −
When requesting a Voluntary Transfer Lock, the procedural documentation published by the RIPE NCC is leading. These procedures must comply with the constraints set by this policy.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
All the Constraints defined below must be followed during the implementation of the policy by the RIPE NCC. All Recommendations should be followed unless there is a strong reason to deviate from them. The Implementation choices explicitly give the RIPE NCC leeway. The RIPE NCC may implement them if they so choose, provided that the choices are explicitly documented.출처 정보 ↗
Reason for pursuing a community policy · Version 2 adds the proponents’ explanation for moving into review: after discussion with RIPE NCC staff, they considered a community policy necessary to implement the service. This is reported procedural rationale, not a newly imposed lock or evidence that every resource holder wants one.
출처 정보 −
There have been requests from parts of the community to implement this option. The policy gives resource holders an option they can use, it doesn’t affect those who don’t want to use it.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
After deliberations with the responsible RIPE NCC staff, we have decided to go ahead and propose this policy. Although others felt it was unnecessary, the RIPE NCC made it clear that it could not implement this option without a policy.출처 정보 ↗
Working-group remit and transfer-policy cross-reference · The added rationale says the proposal stays in the RIPE NCC Services Working Group because it concerns a requested service, with a linked amendment to ripe-682 intended to avoid contradictory transfer-policy wording. The retained version describes that companion amendment but does not reproduce its complete text; no additional transfer restriction can be inferred from the reference alone.
출처 정보 −
This policy only defines the constraints on the implementation of a Voluntary Transfer Lock. It explicitly does not prescribe a specific implementation by RIPE NCC.출처 정보 ↗
출처 정보 +
We decided to leave it in the RIPE NCC Services Working Group as the content of the policy mainly concerns a service that the community wants the RIPE NCC to provide. We added a small update [2] to the transfer policy (ripe-682) to refer to this new service in order to avoid any contradiction between the texts of the policy.출처 정보 ↗
논의 연표
참여 주체
불러오는 중…
출처 및 적용 범위
공개 토론 기록 보관소
- ripencc-address-policy-wg –
- ripencc-accountability-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-agm-nominations-ripe.net –
- ripencc-all-anchors-ripe.net –
- ripencc-anti-abuse-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-atlas-sponsors-ripe.net –
- ripencc-atlas-sw-probes-ripe.net –
- ripencc-bcop-ripe.net –
- ripencc-coc-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-connect-bof-ripe.net –
- ripencc-connect-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-cooperation-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-db-help-ripe.net –
- ripencc-db-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-diversity-ripe.net –
- ripencc-dns-resolver-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-dns-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-dp-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-eb-candidates-ripe.net –
- ripencc-eix-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-election-cc-team-ripe.net –
- ripencc-enum-announce-ripe.net –
- ripencc-enum-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-hackathon-list-ripe.net –
- ripencc-icann-plan-ripe.net –
- ripencc-iot-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ipmap-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ipmt-dev-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ipv6-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-irrtoolset-ripe.net –
- ripencc-lir-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-mat-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-measure-voip-ripe.net –
- ripencc-members-discuss-unmoderated-ripe.net –
- ripencc-members-discuss-ripe.net –
- ripencc-myasntesting-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ncc-announce-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ncc-services-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-opensource-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-persian-lir-ripe.net –
- ripencc-policy-announce-ripe.net –
- ripencc-raci-list-ripe.net –
- ripencc-regional-russia-ripe.net –
- ripencc-regional-ukraine-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-atlas-ambassadors-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-atlas-tools-maintainers-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-atlas-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-chair-discuss-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-db-requirements-tf-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-forum-test-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-list-unmoderated-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-list-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripe-parents-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ripecast-ripe.net –
- ripencc-rirs-lea-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ris-int-ripe.net –
- ripencc-ris-users-ripe.net –
- ripencc-routing-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-rpslng-ripe.net –
- ripencc-security-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-see-regional-ripe.net –
- ripencc-techsec-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-tld-wg-ripe.net –
- ripencc-tt-tf-ripe.net –
- www.ripe.net/community/wg/active-wg/ap/minutes
- ripencc-green-tech-hackathon-orga-ripe.net
- ripencc-nccdays-pc-ripe.net
커버리지
가장 처음 수집된 시점: 1992. 6. 30.
최근 수집: 2026. 11. 14.
