- Elon Musk’s xAI accused of operating 35 methane turbines without permits.
- Environmental groups cite violations of the Clean Air Act in Memphis.
What happened: xAI’s energy use sparks legal and environmental alarms
Elon Musk’s artificial intelligence firm, xAI, has come under scrutiny following revelations that it is operating 35 methane-burning turbines at its Memphis, Tennessee facility — more than double the number it applied to legally use. According to the Southern Environmental Law Center, the turbines are running continuously and emit harmful nitrogen oxides, posing a health risk to surrounding residential communities.
Community advocates such as KeShaun Pearson of Memphis Community Against Pollution have raised concerns to the Shelby County Board of Commissioners, noting the discrepancy between xAI’s permit application and its actual usage. A permit had been submitted for only 15 turbines, but aerial imaging has shown at least 35 are in operation — without the required regulatory approvals.
The facility, housing the “Colossus” supercomputer, is reportedly the size of 13 football fields and supports the chatbot Grok, requiring immense computational power. While xAI has contracts to draw 150MW from the Memphis utility grid, Musk has cited the need for supplementary energy to deal with supply fluctuations.
Critics argue that xAI is effectively operating a power plant without oversight. The Shelby County Health Department and Environmental Protection Agency have been called to intervene, though no formal comment has been issued by either authority or by xAI.
Also read: Elon Musk and SoftBank CEO explore investment opportunities
Also read: Indonesia courts Elon Musk for xAI data centres in Southeast Asia
Why it is important
The controversy highlights a broader issue of regulatory gaps in handling rapid infrastructure expansion for emerging technologies like artificial intelligence. With xAI allegedly bypassing environmental permitting processes, the situation underscores the need for stricter monitoring of industrial-scale AI facilities.
The supercomputer Colossus, central to xAI’s operations, consumes vast amounts of energy, mirroring a growing trend in AI industries. According to Goldman Sachs, queries processed by AI platforms such as ChatGPT require exponentially more electricity than traditional web searches. The majority of that energy in the U.S. continues to be sourced from fossil fuels, intensifying climate change concerns.
Local communities are disproportionately affected, as residential areas near the Memphis facility bear the brunt of the air pollution. Amanda Garcia, a senior attorney at the Southern Environmental Law Center, stated that emissions from the turbines significantly degrade local air quality. The presence of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides is particularly concerning, given their established links to respiratory illness.
Legal loopholes have further complicated the matter. xAI may be using a provision that allows temporary generator use if they are relocated within a year. However, this has raised questions about whether such practices comply with the spirit — if not the letter — of environmental laws.
