Tim McGinnis

Документированные сведения о публичной роли, решениях или участии Tim McGinnis в правовых вопросах могут влиять на инвестиции в сети, доступ на рынок, инфраструктурную политику или границы ответственности; досье отделяет цитируемые сведения от проверки текущей должности.

Доступные данные охватывают Роли: IP Analyst / Hostmaster / LIR Trainer (2002–2005) (RIPE NCC).

Последние 2026-09-25

Роли: IP Analyst / Hostmaster / LIR Trainer (2002–2005) (RIPE NCC)

Уверенность

Публичная роль: Цитируемые открытые источники указывают на Tim McGinnis как на человека, связанного с решениями, судебными делами, управлением или эксплуатацией интернет-инфраструктуры; текущая должность и принадлежность ещё требуют проверки.

Связанные сведения

Tim McGinnis
Secondment Tim McGinnis - AfriNIC (PDPWG)
public people profile
Tim McGinnis
Tim McGinnis aka McTim
public people profile

Последнее обновление: 2026-09-25

Роли

Role:IP Analyst / Hostmaster / LIR Trainer (2002–2005) (RIPE NCC)Ещё не оцененоИсторические сведения

Role:Education Manager and Lead Trainer (2012) (Internet Systems Consortium)Ещё не оцененоИсторические сведения

Role:Former Policy Development Working Group Co-chair (reported in 2015) (AFRINIC)Ещё не оцененоИсторические сведения

Факты из источников

Участие в обсуждении политики RIR

1Участие по реестрам RIR

9Предложения с участием

48Всего сообщений в обсуждениях

7 мая 2008 г.Первое участие

7 дек. 2014 г.Последнее участие

afpub-2008-gen-001hereНеизвестно · 9 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Явная позиция не заявлена
AFPUB-2012-DNS-001No Reverse Unless AssignedПоддержка с изменениями · 6 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Согласованная
Tim continues to seek better assignment registration while revising the enforcement mechanism and clarifying its scope. He explicitly uses discretionary removal authority and explains that direct end-user assignments already entered by registry staff can receive reverse delegation. In June 2013 he offers to withdraw if the community rejects this approach; that conditional offer does not contradict his original invitation to find a better solution.
No Reverse Unless Assigned
Оценка: Согласованная · Tim continues to seek better assignment registration while revising the enforcement mechanism and clarifying its scope. He explicitly uses discretionary removal authority and explains that direct end-user assignments already entered by registry staff can receive reverse delegation. In June 2013 he offers to withdraw if the community rejects this approach; that conditional offer does not contradict his original invitation to find a better solution.
Условия: The draft's MAY wording permits rather than mandates removal of reverse delegation. · The author qualifies his recollection about staff registration; his explanation is not a new adopted policy text. · The June message neither records an actual withdrawal nor proves the absence of community support.
17 апр. 2012 г.
someone will have a better idea about how to encourage the registration of assignments.
5 дек. 2012 г.
pls note, I have used a "MAY" instead of a "SHALL" or a "MUST" in 3.3.
17 дек. 2012 г.
In short, no, it doesn't apply to end-user space.
19 июн. 2013 г.
If there is no consensus that this is the way to rectify the problem of getting people to register their assignments, I would be happy to withdraw this proposal
afpub-2012-gen-002Regional Internet Registry Privacy | AFPUB-2012-GEN-002-DRAFT-02Неизвестно · 1 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Недостаточно доказательств для оценки согласованности
As PDWG co-chair, Tim apologizes for delayed communication and offers an Open Policy Hour slot for the privacy proposal. This is facilitation of discussion, not evidence of support, opposition or a change in his personal privacy position.
Regional Internet Registry Privacy | AFPUB-2012-GEN-002-DRAFT-02
Оценка: Недостаточно доказательств для оценки согласованности · As PDWG co-chair, Tim apologizes for delayed communication and offers an Open Policy Hour slot for the privacy proposal. This is facilitation of discussion, not evidence of support, opposition or a change in his personal privacy position.
Условия: Only a scheduling exchange is included for this policy.
11 мая 2012 г.
would it be ok if we put it in the Open Policy Hour with the other proposals that were made after the deadline?
AFPUB-2012-V4-001AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01Поддержка · 2 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Недостаточно доказательств для оценки согласованности
Tim introduces the 2012 Anycast proposal as a starting point for discussion. This establishes advocacy at that time, but the single reviewed message cannot show whether his position stayed unchanged through later revisions.
AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01
Оценка: Недостаточно доказательств для оценки согласованности · Tim introduces the 2012 Anycast proposal as a starting point for discussion. This establishes advocacy at that time, but the single reviewed message cannot show whether his position stayed unchanged through later revisions.
Условия: Submitting a strawman does not establish consensus or endorsement of every later draft.
17 апр. 2012 г.
Below is the proposal on Anycast I submitted to pdwg last week.
AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01 · Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC region
Оценка: Согласованная · His introduction of an Anycast proposal in 2012 and support for clarification and adoption of the 2014 Anycast proposal show compatible advocacy for an Anycast policy path. They do not establish that the two proposals have identical text or that he endorsed every intervening version.
Условия: The comparison concerns the positions expressed in these messages, not equivalence between the policy versions.
17 апр. 2012 г.
Below is the proposal on Anycast I submitted to pdwg last week.
28 нояб. 2014 г.
sure, I am all for future proofing as APB suggests.
7 дек. 2014 г.
AFPUB-2013-GEN-001AFPUB-2013-GEN-001-DRAFT-02Неизвестно · 3 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Явная позиция не заявлена
AFPUB-2013-V4-001AFPUB-2013-V4-001-DRAFT-01Неизвестно · 5 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Явная позиция не заявлена
afpub-2014-gen-003Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC regionПоддержка · 3 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Согласованная
Tim supports clarifying and future-proofing the 2014 Anycast proposal, then states that he is in favor during last call. The later brief endorsement is compatible with his earlier support for clarification; it does not itself prove that every suggested change was incorporated.
Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC region
Оценка: Согласованная · Tim supports clarifying and future-proofing the 2014 Anycast proposal, then states that he is in favor during last call. The later brief endorsement is compatible with his earlier support for clarification; it does not itself prove that every suggested change was incorporated.
Условия: The final short endorsement supplies no further reasons or implementation evidence.
28 нояб. 2014 г.
sure, I am all for future proofing as APB suggests.
28 нояб. 2014 г.
I would support the change that Alan suggests in the interests of clarity.
7 дек. 2014 г.
in favor.
AFPUB-2012-V4-001-DRAFT-01 · Anycast resource assignments in the AFRINIC region
Оценка: Согласованная · His introduction of an Anycast proposal in 2012 and support for clarification and adoption of the 2014 Anycast proposal show compatible advocacy for an Anycast policy path. They do not establish that the two proposals have identical text or that he endorsed every intervening version.
Условия: The comparison concerns the positions expressed in these messages, not equivalence between the policy versions.
afpub-2014-gen-004Resource Reservations for Internet Exchange PointsНеизвестно · 2 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Явная позиция не заявлена
AFPUB-2026-IPv4-001-DRAFT02IPv4 Soft LandingНеизвестно · 17 Сообщения в обсуждении
Согласованность позиции: Явная позиция не заявлена